As we know, (well I HOPE you know!)
Hollyleaf,
Lionblaze and
Jayfeather's sister, died in sunrise from running into the ancient tunnels that ran under the clans because her belief in the Warrior Code -that she had built her whole life around- had shattered. Anyway, we would think that
Hollyleaf would go to
StarClan, since she is a past clan cat, but is she really deserving of that position? She killed
Ashfur, her
clan mate, because he threatened to reveal that
Leafpool was the mother of
Hollyleaf,
Jayfeather, and
Lionblaze, yet
Hollyleaf does not deserve a position in the Dark Forest where
Tigerstar,
Brokenstar,
Hawlkfrost, and many other EVIL cats lurk.
Hollyleaf wasn't evil or anything, so she really seems to be an oddball.
What I think is that
Hollyleaf walks with Fallen Leaves in the tunnels. Now, your probably wondering,
Woah, who is Fallen Leaves, what tunnels?! Well, here is some background: Fallen Leaves was part of a past "tribe" of cats that lived near the lake. He
traveled into the confusing tunnels under the lake, and he died down there because the underground river flooded, as it does whenever it rains. Fallen Leaves traveled down there because in his "tribe" it was a tradition that if you travel into the tunnels and make it out alive, you will become a
Sharpclaw, which means you are no longer a "kit" and can take care of yourself.
ANYWAY, I think that since
Hollyleaf died in the tunnels, (or so we think, Erin Hunter has not said yes or no if
Hollyleaf is truly dead or not) I think that
Hollyleaf should wander around with Fallen Leaves in the tunnels. I
haven't found anyone on the
Internet that has that theory, and I am rather shocked by that, but as they say, there has to be a first for everything! :)